The Wine PocketList mini course, part 6 of 7
Red Wine Headaches
Do you – or does someone you know – experience severe headaches from even a single glass of red wine on occasion? Why does this affect some people so severely, and others not all?
Personally, I’ve found that any wine in enough quantity will give me a headache. But I digress… The fact is, for some people a glass of red wine is enough to quickly create a pounding headache. There are several different ideas as to the cause. But, it is a real issue. According to an article in the Harvard Health Letter, “The red wine headache is a real if poorly understood phenomenon.”
Below, we’ll talk about possible causes and myths, then focus on solutions if you’re a member of this unfortunate fraternity.
Sulfites: An easy to blame – but inaccurate – target
In winemaking, “sulfite” is a word used to describe sulphur dioxide. Used since ancient times for many purposes, their antioxidant and anti-microbial properties have gained them an important role in modern wine making. The help to inhibit or kill bacteria, helping the fermentation of grapes go more quickly, and cleanly. Sulfites are also a natural and minor by-product of yeast fermentation and thus are produced during the wine fermentation process.
The “contains sulfites” labeling imposed on the wine industry by the FDA was done because studies show that about 1% of the population is allergic to sulfites. They cannot eat many of the other products that contain sulfites, such as dried fruit. It has nothing to do with headaches – those who are allergic will exhibit an allergic reaction, but won’t typically get headaches.
In fact, sweet white wines often contain an even higher level of sulfites than most red wines. And I have yet to meet someone who suffers from “white wine headaches” (absent the obvious reasons).
Tannins: The Pucker Factor
Another school of thought points to tannins as the possible cause of red wine headaches. Tannins are found in the seeds, skins, and stems of grapes, as well as in oak barrels (the newer the barrel, the more). They’re important because they provide flavor, structure, and texture to wine and, like sulfites, have antioxidant traits that aid graceful aging. Wines with noticeable tannins (detectable by a dry, puckery, sensation) are referred to as “tannic.”
Another Harvard Health Letter study indicates that tannins can cause the release of serotonin, a neurotransmitter that can trigger headaches in migraine sufferers. But tannins also occur in tea and chocolate – and they’re not often labeled as being responsible for headaches.
Histamines: The Skin of the Grape
In the skin of every grape is a chemical substance called “histamines.” They occur naturally as the vines bud and ripen. And many people are histamine sensitive – women typically more so then men.
Histamines dilate blood vessels in the brain, which may cause headaches if you’re one of the people so affected. Although both red and white wines contain histamines, red wines are in contact with the skins of the grapes for longer than white wines, and generally have a higher content of histamines than white – some studies cite levels ranging from 20–200% higher.
But fermented and aged foods including things like salami, cheese and sourdough bread are also high in histamines.
Red Wine Headaches: Is There a Cure?
If you really love red wine there are several things you can do. First, we’ll dispense with obvious. Headaches that come on hours after you’ve had your wine are almost always caused by overindulgence. You’ll notice that almost all typical “red wine headaches” start in 15 to 30 minutes. If you can’t recall how many glasses you’ve had, you know the answer already.
Other advice includes:
Eat before drinking red wine. (It’s best with food anyhow, right?)
Try a non-sedating antihistamine such as Allegra or Claritin before drinking red wine. I wouldn’t advocate you try this without the proper disclaimer, so check with your family doctor or allergist before trying this solution. But, we’ve had other histamine-sensitive readers report this helped them a great deal, so it deserves a cautious mention.
Try a non-sedating antihistamine such as Allegra or Claritin before drinking red wine. I wouldn’t advocate you try this without the proper disclaimer, so check with your family doctor or allergist before trying this solution. But, we’ve had other histamine-sensitive readers report this helped them a great deal, so it deserves a cautious mention.
Aspirin or Ibuprofen A 1991 blind controlled study suggests that taking one of these up to an hour prior to wine drinking helped about 80% of sufferers prevent a headache. When drinking red wine. But be careful; these types of medications can have a negative effect on your stomach when mixed with too much alcohol.
The best long-term solution requires time and effort. Essentially, you need to find the wines that work for you. Many red wine headache sufferers are fine with some red wines, and not with others. Experimentation is the only long-term solution. Try different Varietals, brands and countries. Start with a half-glass or so, and see what happens. You’ll usually know in 15 minutes if you’re OK. If so, note the type and origin, and enjoy another glass or two.
Many of the reds wines I’ve tried are so good, I know I’d go to some extreme lengths to enjoy a glass – or two. I hope some of these ideas help you!
Next Week, Chapter 6: “Restaurant Wine Prices”
Perhaps you’ve noticed a bottle of wine you purchased at a bog-box retailer on the wine list at a favorite restaurant… for 300% more than you paid. There’s got to be a limit, right? In Chapter 6, the last in the mini-wine course series, we explore how and why restaurants charge what they do for wine.
Cheers!
– Michael Hinshaw, Publisher, the Wine PocketList