The Wine PocketList mini course, part 7 of 7
Restaurant Wine Prices and Corkage Fees
If you’re like most consumers, you aren’t very happy about the wine prices restaurants typically charge. For many, it’s a purely monetary reaction. Why pay $60.00 for a wine you know retails for just over $20.00? It seems excessive. Some wine consumers elect to bring in a bottle or two of their own, electing to pay restaurant corkage fees instead of a significant mark-up. So, many restaurants have boosted their corkage, prompting author Anthony Dias Blue to dub them “screwage” fees.
So what and how do restaurants set their prices? And what can money-conscious wine-lovers do to enjoy great wines with great meals out?
Restaurant Wine Pricing: The Why and the How.
Restaurateurs point to lots of reasons a 200 to 300% markup over retail is both reasonable and usual. The dining experience, wine storage costs, spoilage and rising overhead are but a few. The argument can make sense, until you realize that restaurants buy at wholesale, which is about half the cost of retail. 400 to 600% markups sound over the top no matter how you defend it.
Some establishments charge these prices as part of their image; often those that are trying to create an “exclusive” atmosphere for the privileged or target tourists looking for a fine dining experience in a new town or city. Others unashamedly point to the profit made, and its contribution to overhead.
But not all restaurants adhere to this. Some set a fixed markup on all bottles (say $10 per bottle). Others are making efforts to keep customers happy by dropping wine prices overall. But what it comes down to is that a big portion of the bottom line comes from wine mark-ups, and that simply isn’t negotiable for many establishments.
Corkage: Bringing Your Own
Brining a bottle of your own is a great way to ensure you get the best wine at the best price. Fees for corkage vary widely, ranging from a low of $10 or so to as high as (in the case of wine country hot spot The French Laundry) $50.00, raised from $30 in late 2000.
Why so high? High corkage fees are defended with many of the same arguments used for wine mark-ups. Certainly, set up and fine glassware does have a cost, and in many better quality restaurants, the cost of a broken glass can be significant.
And for restaurants such as the French Laundry that work hard to provide an extensive wine list matched to the vision of the chef and/or sommelier, it is understandable that they would discourage guests bringing their own wines. After all, the masterful pairing of food and wine does bring out the best of each.
Three Pieces of Advice for Wine Lovers
Wine and food go together like, well, wine and food. And for me, eating out regularly (and well) is something I and my family enjoy a great deal. At the same time, I don’t happily pay an exorbitant markup either. So I’ve come up with three simple pieces of advice to help balance prudent purchasing with my desire to drink good wine with a meal out.
Order a bottle instead of a glass. Wine by the glass is a false economy. At $8 a glass in even the most basic restaurants, a $10 retail bottle of wine – that might sell for $25 to $30 on the wine list – turns into a $40 bottle after the average five pours. It didn’t take me long to notice that one glass at a time for two of us almost always ends up costing more than a bottle over a good meal.
Expand your wine horizons. People tend to buy wines from the wine list one of three different ways. They’ll buy a wine that they know is good, and is familiar. Often, these are the high-priced wines that restaurants know you know is good – wines like a Silver Oak Cabernet, or Opus One. Or, they buy a lower-priced wine that sounds familiar. Surprise, advertising works! But it can’t guarantee a good wine value.
My method – and the one I advocate for you – is to expand your horizons. By learning more about better but less well-known wines (naturally, I think the Wine PocketList is the best tool for this) you’ll find reasonably priced wines that will be great a accompaniment to your meal. It’s nice to know that the Zinfandel you’re enjoying for a marked-up $32 puts the better-known $68 bottle to shame.
Bring your own and pay the corkage fee. As long as you call in advance to find out if the spot you’re going allows diners to bring their own wine, and you’re comfortable doing so, going this route almost guarantees the best wine for the best price. Though you’ll hate paying $15 for the use of their corkscrew and glasses, you’ll get what you like at a significantly lower price.
The fact is, restaurants are in business for the same reason any other enterprise is: to make money. As the consumer, you always have the option of voting with your feet, and going somewhere else. But many great restaurants deserve to be tried and enjoyed, regardless of their wine pricing policies. So expand your horizons, and enjoy.
I hope you enjoyed our “mini wine course.” This Chapter is the last one, though you can be certain we’ll continue to send you interesting and relevant information in the months ahead in the form of the monthly VinConnections email newsletter, and our weekly wine picks.
Cheers!
– Michael Hinshaw, Publisher, the Wine PocketList