From the Wine PocketList archives, 1994–2007

Press about the original Wine PocketList

What newspapers and magazines said about the printed PocketList and the website, 1994–2004.

“You don’t have to spend a week’s salary to buy a good bottle of wine.”

Chicago Sun-Times, 1994-12

Announced the new periodical, a list of more than 500 imported and domestic wines at $15 or less, each made in lots of at least 1,000 cases.

“Spending hard-earned money on a disappointing bottle stifles exploration far more than using a list. For many wine drinkers, [The Wine PocketList] could be quite useful...”

Dayton Daily News, 1994-12

Profiled John Vankat, then a botany professor at Miami University, and how the list of well-reviewed wines he kept for himself became the PocketList, graded A+ to B+.

“...having this list in concise form was simpler than carrying along several wine publications to a store.”

The Milwaukee Journal, 1995-01

Described how John Vankat compiled and averaged ratings from major wine publications into a pocket-size list of more than 500 wines at $15 or less, alternating American and imported issues.

“Beyond its use as a buying guide, [The Wine PocketList] is interesting reading, much like box scores are for the sports fan.”

The Virginian-Pilot, 1996-02

Told how John Vankat, a hit-or-miss wine buyer who taught botany in Ohio, organized wine ratings on his computer and turned the list his friends kept asking for into a business.

“Even though I know a lot about wine, shopping for it can still be mystifying, frustrating, and ultimately wallet draining. That’s why I really like [The Wine PocketList]”

Fine Cooking, 1996-03

Recommended the Quarterly PocketList of Top Rated Wines for $15 or Less, with more than 500 well-regarded wines per issue and alternating domestic and imported issues.

“One of the best quick guides to wine is the “Quarterly PocketList of Top Rated Wines.””

Richmond Times-Dispatch, 1996-07

Explained that the guide combined top wines from nine national publications into one grade, A+ to B+, required at least 1,000 cases, and added a Splurge section for wines of $16–30.

“With PocketList in tow, the sea of colored glass in the supermarket wine section suddenly becomes interpretable.”

U.S. Airways Attaché Magazine, 1998-03

Profiled John Vankat and the PocketList, a pocket guide built from about a dozen wine publications, which by then had subscribers in 46 states.

“How would you expect a college professor to grade wines? Seems only natural to give the better ones A’s and B’s, which is what you will find in the unique Wine PocketList.”

The Detroit News, 2000-07

Explained how Vankat combined reviews from 10 wine magazines, adjusted for their differences, into letter grades for wines of $30 or less from wineries making at least 1,000 cases.

“There is nowhere near enough good wine to go around… [that’s why] the Wine Pocketlist is uniquely tailored to our need...”

San Francisco Examiner Magazine, 2000-10

A long essay on learning to buy wine as a beginner, in which the writers took the Quarterly PocketList into the wine aisle as their guide.

“One of the finest and most helpful publications that I have come across…”

Arkansas Democrat-Gazette

Quoted on the Wine PocketList site; the full review is not in the archive.

“I like this publication because anyone can find a good, expensive wine; the trick is to find good, inexpensive wines. The Wine PocketList helps do just that……”

The Bakersfield Californian

Quoted on the Wine PocketList site; the full review is not in the archive.

“The Wine PocketList [is] a truly superb guide for wine stocking and selection on a reasonable budget.”

The Midwest Book Review

Quoted on the Wine PocketList site; the full review is not in the archive.

“You, too, can play the game – and buy a decent bottle of wine without having to choose the pretty label…..”

The State

Quoted on the Wine PocketList site; the full review is not in the archive.