From the Wine PocketList archives, 1994–2007Emailed to new Vin Connections subscribers, one letter a week; letter written by October 2003

The Wine PocketList mini course, part 2 of 7

A Note about Wine Rating Systems

I’m sure you’ve seen the shelf-talkers in the store, touting 86 points for this wine, 94 for that. “At last” you say, “an objective method to purchase wine.”

Well…maybe.

The fact is, wine tasting is, has always been, and always will be, an intensely personal experience. And for many, there is still a mystique surrounding fine wine. (A mystique that many in the wine industry have an interest in perpetuating – while our mission at the Wine PocketList is to totally de-mystify the enjoyment of good wine).

Why Rate Wines at All?

People are bound to have differences of opinion on something as deliciously subjective as wine. The different wine rating systems and the vocal dialogue surrounding their efficacy is proof alone of this point.

Enjoying wine should be simple. You taste it, and either you like it or you don’t. For the average wine buyer, scoring is a subjective measurement, but it is a measurement. Certainly, it’s more reliable than the shape of a bottle or the design of the label. Or, heaven forbid, the assumption that price always equals quality.

The 100 Point System

Though the UC Davis 20 point system is widely used in competitions, the wine rating system most commonly known by consumers in the United States is the 100 point system. Setting aside the fact that it is really only a 50-point system (all a wine has to do to earn 50 points is show up), the level of implied precision behind the numbers on the 100-point scale is virtually meaningless to the average consumer.

Would you really be able to tell the objective quality difference between a wine that’s rated 89 and a wine rated 90? Or between a 94 and a 95? In fact, when we’ve blind tasted against this scale, we found that wine “X” might earn a 91 one day, and an 89 on another. Still a good wine, but for most of us (including the vast majority of professional wine tasters) it’s simply too subjective to consistently discern the differences that would affect a score by a few points.

Add to this the fact that each individual, publication or group that rates by a 100-point system applies it slightly differently, and it further muddles the implied value of a given score. For instance, you’re not likely to find that the Wine Spectator and Wine Advocate award points using the same set of criteria. Wine Enthusiast rates differently still.

Letter Grades

This is why the Wine PocketList utilizes a grading system that people intuitively grasp. Letter grades. After all, which of us doesn’t understand that an A+ is the best you can get? Or that a C is mediocre? At the same time, a letter grade is not absolute. An A+ doesn’t have to be 100 percent. In school, you can get an A+ with 98, 99 or 100 percent. 94 percent to 97 percent earns you an A. And so on.

Here’s a top-level breakdown of what you can expect from wines that have earned different grades in the Wine PocketList system:

A+: Truly Outstanding As good as gets. Flawless, nearly perfect in every way;

a wine that brings you to your knees.

A: Exceptional An “A” rated wine should knock your socks off, and is highly recommended.

A–: Excellent These wines are well worth seeking out, especially if they can retain an

A– rating with more than one review.

B+: Very Good These wines are typically very well made with some obvious appeal.

An equally important part of our process is to appropriately “weight” the scores. Our weighting criteria are designed to balance price, publication bias and other factors, and help ensure consistent ratings validity across all Varietals and vineyards. For example, an 89 in Wine Spectator will not have the same weight as an 89 by Robert Parker, and a $30 wine with an 89 point rating will likely be dropped, while an $8 wine with the same score is probably worth a try, and will remain.

Understanding that wine ratings are not absolute, and that the ultimate judge of any wine is you, and you alone, is key to enjoying new wines. And next time you see any wine touting a point score of under 88 points, know that even the experts they’re quoting gave it a “B” or less.

Next Week, Chapter 2: Price vs. Quality

Have you ever wondered if a $45 wine is that much better than a wine half that price? You’ll receive Chapter 2 in one week. In it, we explore what it actually costs to make wine – and why price isn’t a definitive measure of quality.

Cheers!

– Michael Hinshaw, Publisher, the Wine PocketList

The Wine PocketList