From the Wine PocketList archives, 1994–2007First published in The Cincinnati Enquirer, March 8, 1998 · On winepocketlist.com by April 2000

Straight Talk about Wine

Taking Notes at a Wine Tasting

When counting your blessings, be sure to include wine tastings.

A wine tasting can and should be great fun. But if you want it to be more, you’ll need to jot down some notes about the wines.

When I taste wines at home, I evaluate more than 20 different aspects of color, aroma and taste. But that’s far too many considerations when sampling wines at a large tasting.

At wine tastings, even ultra wine geeks normally write only a few simple words – just enough to help remember which wines to purchase after the tasting.

So what aspects of color, aroma and taste are most important?

Color

I suggest that there are only two critical color characteristics for most wines at most tastings: intensity and hue.

Normally, these characteristics are easy to determine, but the dim lighting at most wine tastings may present a challenge.

Intensity is the depth of color, so just note “pale”, “medium”, “deep” or “dark”.

Of course white wines are lighter than red wines, so as for any characteristic, always compare wines of the same varietal – chardonnay to chardonnay, not chardonnay to sauvignon blanc.

Hue is what most people mean by “color”. Red wines tend to be various shades of purple to red, and white wines usually range from yellow (occasionally with a greenish tinge) to gold.

Aroma

As with color, there are only two key characteristics: intensity and complexity. These can be more difficult to judge than color, so swirl your glass to provide more aroma.

Intensity is the strength of the aromas. Most wines have “light”, “medium” or “strong” aromas.

Complexity refers to the variety or diversity of aromas perceived. Straight-forward terms are “simple”, “pleasant” and “complex”.

Wine writers are renowned for flowery descriptions of the specific aromas (and tastes) of wine. If you are influenced by whether a wine appears to have aromas of parsley, sage, rosemary and thyme – or even of Simon and Garfunkel – indulge yourself too.

Taste

Of the many aspects of taste, only three are essential to note: body, balance and length.

Body is the weight or texture of a wine in your mouth. Terms include “light”, “medium” and “full”. Nearly all white wines are lighter in body than red wines – so again, always compare wines of the same varietal.

Balance refers to your perception of the combination of sweetness and acidity in white wines, plus tannin in red wines. Wines that overemphasize one of these tastes are “unbalanced”, because they are too “sweet”, “acidic” or “tannic”. Other wines have “good” to “excellent” balance.

Length refers to how long the taste lingers in your mouth. Simple terms range from “short” (disappearing a few seconds after swallowing) to “lingering” (lasting 60 seconds or more).

Overall

Although I’ve made the case for looking at different aspects of a wine, the key to wine evaluation is how well all aspects blend. Therefore, end your short description with an overall grade for the wine.

I suggest using a grading scale that is simple and meaningful such as an A-B-C scale, and adding a check mark when the wine strikes you as truly special.

There you have it – with just a few simple notes, a grade and an eye on price, you’ll know which wines are the best for you to buy.

Here’s a crib sheet for your use:

COLOR

Intensity: thin, pale, medium, deep, dark

Hue (white wines): greenish tinge, yellow, gold, brown

Hue (red wines): purple, purplish red, red, reddish brown, brown

AROMA

Intensity: very light, light, medium, strong, very strong

Complexity: simple, pleasant, complex, powerful

TASTE

Body: very light/thin, light, medium, full, heavy

Balance: unbalanced (sweet/acidic/tannic), good, very good, excellent

Length: short (a few seconds), moderate, extended, lingering (over 60 seconds)

OVERALL

Final Grade: A B C

– John Vankat

– John Vankat