From the Wine PocketList archives, 1994–2007First published in The Cincinnati Enquirer, November 16, 1997 · On winepocketlist.com by April 2000

Straight Talk about Wine

Does the Shape and Size of Wine Glasses Influence Taste?

Riedel Crystal – the world’s most famous manufacturer of specialty wine glasses – would have you believe that the size and shape of wine glasses so greatly affect aroma and taste that you need different glasses for chardonnay, sauvignon blanc and other varietals.

The Austrian manufacturer has a lot at stake. Tailoring glasses to different varietals is the company’s primary marketing pitch.

Frankly, I was skeptical of this notion, especially for average wine drinkers.

After all, consumers have a lot at stake too, as good wine glasses are expensive.

Testing Riedel’s Claim

Although Riedel conducts its own glass tastings across the U.S., I wanted to reduce the possibility of bias. Riedel agreed to cooperate with my glass tasting – the first ever done outside the company.

Riedel loaned me several “starter sets” from the Vinum Series, their second highest priced line. Each set retails for about $90 and includes three tulip shaped glasses for sauvignon blanc (7 3/4 ounces), chardonnay (12 3/8), and cabernet (21 1/2), plus one globular, brandy-snifter shaped glass for pinot noir (24 3/4).

I organized two tasting panels: one for intermediate wine drinkers who claimed no special tasting expertise; and a second advanced panel with extensive tasting experience.

I began by pouring a sauvignon blanc into all four glasses for each panelist. I then asked the panelists to rank the glasses (remember that only one glass was designed for sauvignon blanc). This was repeated for chardonnay, pinot noir, and cabernet. All wines cost about $15 per bottle.

Did glasses influence taste?

Resoundingly yes! Panelists always found differences among the four glasses when filled with the same wine – except one intermediate panelist who ranked the glasses equal for one wine.

Even pairs of glasses were infrequently found equal, especially by members of the advanced panel. As one panelist exclaimed, “I can’t believe the difference!”

In general, the advanced panelists more strongly supported the idea of different glasses for different wines. Also, they found greater differences among glasses for the red wines than for the whites.

Did panelists pick the appropriate glass?

Here the results were more mixed. The intermediate panel ranked the “right” glass highest only 25 percent of the time, the same as expected by chance alone. However, members of the advanced panel selected it an impressive 75 percent of the time.

Were certain styles preferred overall?

Yes. The intermediate panel found the large, pinot noir glass to be best overall, even for white wines. The advanced panel favored the cabernet and chardonnay glasses.

Would panelists purchase the glasses?

The intermediate panelists were divided on this true test of the glasses: one would not purchase, two were uncertain, and one would. The advanced panelists were ready to buy, although one would limit himself to two styles. As another panelist said, “I’m sold —these glasses really enhance the total wine experience by highlighting the color, bouquet and taste.”

My Findings and Recommendations

I tried the glasses and found surprisingly large differences. Most remarkable was that the pinot noir was nearly undrinkable in the smaller two glasses (too acidic for my tastes) but was fine in the larger two.

Overall, I liked the chardonnay glass best for both white wines and the pinot noir glass best for both reds. However, if I was to purchase only one style, it would be the cabernet – I ranked it second for every wine.

Based on the panels’ feedback and my own tasting, I recommend average wine drinkers purchase two sets of glasses, one for whites and one for reds. Advanced wine drinkers should consider a broader selection of glasses, especially for favorite varietals.

Regardless of your level of experience with wine, my bottom line recommendation is to enhance your wine drinking experiences at home by purchasing high quality glasses – whether made by Riedel or another manufacturer.

Riedel glasses can be ordered from most wine stores.

– John Vankat

– John Vankat