From the Wine PocketList archives, 1994–2007The 2006 PocketList · reviews from Nov 1999 to Mar 2006 · prices as listed then

Penley

South Australia, Australia · 5 graded wines · vintages 1999–2000 · $25

2 wines 1 wine 2 wines

Chardonnay

Chardonnay · Coonawarra

2000IE: individual evaluations: A$25Reviewed May 2002
1999IE: individual evaluations: A plus$25Reviewed Feb 2002

Shiraz

Syrah · Coonawarra

1999IE: individual evaluations: A plus$25Reviewed Feb 2002

Phoenix

Cabernet Sauvignon · Coonawarra

1999IE: individual evaluations: A minus, A minus$25Reviewed Jul 2001 · 5,000 cases

Earlier vintages, as graded then: ’97 A− · ’98 A−

Shiraz, Hyland

Syrah · Coonawarra

1999IE: individual evaluations: A minus, A$25Reviewed Mar 2003 · 5,000 cases

The PocketList’s grades for wines reviewed between Nov 1999 and Mar 2006. These vintages are long gone from the shelves. How the grades worked then.