How the grades worked, 1994–2007
The Wine PocketList gave each wine one letter grade, from A+ down to B+, built from the reviews in the major wine periodicals. Next to the grade it showed the individual evaluations (IE) behind it. This page collects how the PocketList explained its method at the time.
What went into a grade
From the About page of the 2003–2008 site:
- We Do the Homework for You: Our staff analyzes ALL wines reviewed in the major wine periodicals. Every month, our staff analyzes the hundreds of wines recently reviewed by wine critics around the world, choosing only the most highly rated and affordable wines from the top wine periodicals such as International Wine Cellar, Wine Advocate, Wine Spectator, and others. So instead of just one expert’s opinion, the Wine PocketList gives you better odds of finding the best wine for you.
- We Only Include Highly Rated Wines. Of the hundreds of wines reviewed in periodicals each month, many review wines that don’t make the cut. For some it’s interesting to read about a $60 wine that scores an 87, but it’s not very useful. After all, why drink it if it’s only okay? That’s why we only include wines that amass an average grade of B+ or better.
- We Focus on the Best Price. For most of us, spending even $20 on a bottle of wine is a big deal. And since we find thousands of highly rated wines each year for $30 or less whose scores go head-to-head with wines costing $40, $60, $80 a bottle and more, our subscribers spend less and get better wine.
- We Give You Wines You Actually Have a Chance of Finding. Why read about a spectacular wine with a production run of 225 cases, since it can only be found at the winery or through member’s-only mailing lists? That’s why we do our best to only include wines with production runs of over 1000 cases. And you can search for Widely Available wines (wines with a case production of 20,000 or more), increasing the odds you’ll find it in your local store.
- This is a Grading System We Can All Understand. Rather than the sometimes confusing 100-point scale, where five points can mean the difference between greatness and obscurity, the Wine PocketList grades on a fairer – and easier to understand – letter grade scale. You’ll only find wines graded A+, A, A−, and B+. Anything lower and why bother? (See Wine Numbers for more on this.)
Why letter grades, not 100 points
From the FAQ: “Why do you use letter grades instead of something better known like the 100-point system?”
A Rating Scale Everyone Can Understand and Use
Most of us are familiar with the 100-point system used by many of the top wine magazines. But we’ve seen experts and everyday wine lovers alike prove that this system alone can’t assure consistent results. One reason is that different reviewers apply it differently. Another is that each of us has a different taste bias.
Then there are other systems, such as the highly regarded U.C. Davis 20 point system, and The Connoisseur’s Guide to Wine well-known “puff” scale. How can one system take all these into account in a way everyone can understand? Our answer: letter grades.
Letter Grades; Only B+ or Better Included!
At the Wine PocketList, we search and compile wine reviews and ratings from the world’s most highly regarded wine publications, and select only those wines that fit our parameters. Then our highly acclaimed proprietary system crunches the numbers to deliver a score that each of us can easily understand: letter grades.
By using A+, A, A− and B+ (anything lower and it’s not special enough for a recommendation) we give you a better sense of what wines are worth a try based on their prices, how much you like the Varietal, what you know about the wineries’ past wines, etc.
What the codes meant
From the FAQ: “What are the definitions for the codes used in individual wine ratings?”
Grade: [A−]
Our grades represent a composite score developed using our proprietary system to blend wine quality and scoring information.
Vintage: 1999
This describes both the year of the actual grape harvest as well as the year the wine was made.
Price: $12
The prices quoted in the Wine PocketList are the “suggested retail” prices quoted by the wineries and the distributors. Though these are close to what you’d pay at the winery, (and Less than half what you’ll pay at a restaurant) you’ll often find discounts of 20% and more off these prices at retail.
Individual Evaluations: IE: A, A−, B+
This represents the number of individual reviews and ratings on which the composite grade is based, primarily representing individual reviews in top wine periodicals converted to our scale.
Wine PocketList Exclusive Categories: WPL: BBC, W, S, B
There are four Exclusive PocketList categories, and many Wines rated by the PocketList will fall into one of these Special designations. There are also thousands of other Wines online that are great selections and don’t necessarily fit into one of these four categories.
[W] Widely Available: These wines typically have bottling of 20,000 cases or more, making them widely available in most regions of the U.S.
[BBC] Top Buy-by-the-Case: Based on multiple, good reviews and a solid history, these are wines you can purchase by the case to grow your cellar with confidence today, and into the future!
[B] Bargain Wines: Top-rated wines for $10 or less. Most of these can go head to head with a typical $30 bottle sporting a fancy label…and beat it hands down.
[S] Splurge Wines: For most of us, spending more than $25 on a bottle of wine isn’t something we do lightly. These are wines that, while more expensive, are well worth the price.
Finding wines by type and price
From the FAQ: “I’m particularly interested in shopping for a type of wine, or want to look up a certain wine price (like Italian wine prices or Australian wine prices). How can the Wine PocketList help me find them?”
Once a wine is in the Wine PocketList (scoring a B+ or better, with a retail price of $30 a bottle or less) you can search based on almost any parameter you choose. For instance, you can search for all Australian Chardonnay that scored an “A” or above. Then you could sort these results by wine price, winery, or grade.
The resulting wine list can be saved in your Virtual Cellar, and printed out in our “PocketList” format to take to the store. Each time you search, you’ll get a wine shopping list and list of suggested retail wine prices customized to your preferences.
How the Quarterly PocketList chose its wines
The printed PocketList’s method, as the 2000 site described it:
To produce the PocketList, Vankat surveys 10 major wine periodicals:
- Connoisseur’s Guide to California Wine
- International Wine Cellar
- Underground Wine Journal
- Wine Access (Canada)
- Wine Advocate (Robert Parker)
- Wine Enthusiast
- The Wine News
- Wine Spectator
- Wine & Spirits
- Wine X
From these sources, he selects wines which:
- Received evaluations of 88–100 for $15 wines and 90–100 for $16–30 wines — or 86–87 if widely available
- Cost $15 or less for regular wines or $16–30 for splurge wines
- Have a production of at least 1000 cases
The evaluations are entered into a database and adjusted for differences in evaluation scales. A composite grade is produced on an A, B, C scale for each wine. Only wines rated at least B+ for $15 wines and A− for $16–30 wines are included in the PocketList.