From the Wine PocketList archives, 1994–2007Emailed to new Vin Connections subscribers, one letter a week; letter written by October 2003

The Wine PocketList mini course, part 5 of 7

Wine Descriptions

You’ll find extravagant prose describing the aromas and flavors of wines in almost every wine magazine or periodical. For example, here’s a description we came across for an $8 Cabernet Sauvignon: “A bouquet of vanillin oak, cedar and mocha with wisps of cinnamon. Full-bodied tobacco, tea and dark cedar flavors with tart acids in the background. Persistent, coffee-spiked finish.”

That’s nine different aromas and flavors—all in one $8 wine. Does that mean that these aromas and flavors aren’t legitimate? No. There’s little doubt that the descriptions are real...to the people who wrote them.

What’s Real for One Expert Isn’t Real for Another

One head-to-head tasting for the Wine Spectator featured two authorities—one from California, the other from Bordeaux—comparing 40 Cabernet Sauvignons from California and France.

The results? Vastly different experiences and opinions on both quality and taste. In fact, the two experts disagreed on nearly 90 percent of the 40 wines. Their tasting notes had no descriptive words in common for 60 percent of the wines, and only one word in common for 25 percent.

For example, one found “bell pepper, green olive, ripe, lush currant and black cherry” in a Cabernet by Stag’s Leap. But the other found “berry, earth, chocolate and coconut” in the same wine. Yes, currants and cherries may be berries… but peppers and olives don’t remind me of earth, chocolate and coconut in any way.

Are Wine Descriptions Useful at All?

Does this mean that the excessive prose we’ve been conditioned to accepting as a normal part of wine descriptions isn’t useful? The answer to this question depends entirely on what your use is.

I certainly wouldn’t use them as a buying guide, since the chances are slim any descriptions you read will mirror your own experience.

But the prose has other value, primarily as a way to increase your own understanding of wine, and also for those who really enjoy the experience of tasting, sharing and comparing wine with friends. That’s the most important point about trying to describe aromas and flavors — it adds to the understanding and enjoyment of wine.

So the next time you read that “notes of floral and mint trickle through the core of cherry flavors” in a wine you’ve purchased, take it with a grain of salt (or mint, or cherry). Try the wine yourself and see what you find.

That’s Why we Don’t Include Wine Descriptions in the Wine PocketList

We see multiple reviews on the same wines in different publications all the time. And we can’t recall the last time two reviews found the same series of descriptors to describe the same wine.

The fact is, people can’t – and shouldn’t – expect to consistently find the same aromas and flavors in wines. This applies to experts, avid enthusiasts, and everyday wine lovers alike. After all, we each have different taste buds, different tasting experiences, and different taste.

So, while describing wine can help each of us articulate the experience that we have with a given wine, that experience simply isn’t consistent from palate to palate. This natural lack of a consistent measure led us to the decision that descriptions don’t belong in the Wine PocketList.

But we encourage you to find those wines that you enjoy, go ahead and describe them, and carry on a spirited discussion with your friends and family!

Expect to agree and disagree. Expect to learn. And learn to enjoy.

Next Week, Chapter 5: “Red Wine Headaches”

Do you – or does someone you know – experience severe headaches from even a glass of red wine on occasion? Why does this affect some people so severely, and others not all? Find out next week in Chapter 5 of our mini-wine course, when we expose the truth about red wine headaches and “added sulfites.”

Cheers!

– Michael Hinshaw, Publisher, the Wine PocketList

The Wine PocketList