The Wine PocketList mini course, part 3 of 7
Wine Price vs. Wine Quality
We’ve always maintained that a good wine doesn’t have to cost an arm and a leg, and in fact, a high price tag doesn’t always translate into a great wine.
But why the disparity between a widely discussed $1.99 brand versus a much ballyhooed $180 Bordeaux? Or more realistically, between a luscious $15 Spanish Tempranillo and a $65 Napa Cab? Not to malign Napa, one of our favorite places on earth, but it does sometimes seem to be tied up in hype.
Recent figures show that it can cost about $5 to make a Bordeaux that sells for $50 retail. Hand-raised “garage wines”, first growths, low-yield vineyards and drastic weather years can obviously cost more, and higher-volume wines less.
What Does It Cost to Make a Bottle of Wine?
The first and most important ingredient is grapes. They can add from $1.40 to $14.00 per bottle, with the high end representing grapes from the most famous Napa acreage.
Wineries spend a great deal of money – some, up to $100,000 – on label design, with printing for average wine label costs about 25 cents. Corks start at a dime and run up to .75 cents, and bottles range from .50 cents to $2.00. The biggest difference in these is for the “look and feel”; smoother, longer corks cost more. Taller, thicker bottles with high punts (the bump on the underside of the bottle) look more elegant – and cost more. And of course storage, marketing, overhead and other expenses all add up. But other than the grapes, nothing here adds to the quality of the wine.
For the story on Napa prices, you also need to figure in the cost of land. Is it the wine drinker’s fault that a Napa acre has been known to go for $300,000? How much gets tacked on to recoup that kind of investment? As with so many things, perception and demand fuel price as well – particularly in this area.
How do Wine Price and Quality Connect?
There is no doubt that quality and price connect to a certain degree. Below a certain price point – in our experience typically in the $8 a bottle range – it’s rare that you find very good or better wines. As a wine maker told us on a recent visit to Napa, “people make mediocre wine from good grapes all the time... but you just can’t make good wine from bad grapes.”
But as prices rise from $10 to $15 or $20 a bottle, they begin to reflect that oldest of all economic maxims: the law of supply and demand. The most important ingredients in the decision to change the retail price of a wine are scarcity and prestige. To quote a wine industry insider, “The thing you’re paying for as you move up would be prestige, scarcity and, to some extent, intensity of flavor.” (We’ll just take the flavor, thank you!)
What You Can Expect for $30 a Bottle and Under.
Here’s a great example of the disconnect between cost and quality. On the Wine PocketList scale, an A+ is as good a grade as you can get – no matter what the bottle costs. This A+ rating (by way of example) is achieved by well under 5% of ALL wines reviewed, at all prices.
Of the several hundred A+ rated wines in the Wine PocketList, they are pretty evenly distributed between the $30 2000 Mills Reef Elspeth Syrah “Mere Road Vineyard” from Australia (which I found recently for $26 and change at EnoCollection www.enocollection.com) to the $10, 2001 “Alvarinho” Albarino by Quinta da Pedra from Portugal.
In short, there are many wineries outside the rarified sphere of Napa and Bordeaux that are producing amazingly good wines. And while these good people also have to wrestle with growing the grapes, buying corks, bottles, French oak barrels, and a host of other operating costs, they’re not usually tacking on such a generous land and prestige fee.
So, they end up with a wine that costs $36 a case rather than $80 a case to produce, and the savvy consumer gets him or herself a great $12 bottle of wine (or less!).
And that’s what we call a bargain.
Next Week, Chapter 3: “Shelf Talkers.”
Have you ever purchased a wine based on what you read or saw on a small card placed next to the or on the shelf below it? These cards are called “shelf talkers,” a marketing staple of wine retailers and wine makers throughout the United States. In Chapter 3, which you’ll receive next week, you’ll learn how to read between the lines…
Cheers!
– Michael Hinshaw, Publisher, the Wine PocketList