From the Wine PocketList archives, 1994–2007

The story of the Wine PocketList, 1994–2007

From 1994 to 2007, the Wine PocketList read the major wine critics and boiled their reviews down to one letter grade, A+ to B+, for wines $35 and under. John Vankat, PhD, a college professor, started it as a printed list small enough for a pocket: the Quarterly PocketList of Wine. In late 2002 it moved online as a members’ database, with Michael Hinshaw as publisher. The last list was published in 2006.

The sections below are the PocketList’s own words from the time.

How it started

From the PocketList’s FAQ (2003–2008):

Founded in 1994, the Wine PocketList is the brainchild of John L. Vankat, PhD, professor and avid wine enthusiast. After years of poring over wine publications for favorably reviewed wines and compiling wine prices and lists of anything well reviewed by multiple publications (especially at a good price), he had so many friends asking for copies of his wine lists that John decided to launch a business.

After years of refinement, the Wine PocketList went from print to digital in late 2002 to give our members the added benefits of a robust database with search and sort criteria.

The Quarterly PocketList

Before the website, the PocketList was a printed periodical. The 2000 site described it like this:

The Quarterly PocketList of Top-Rated Wines is a unique wine periodical that conveniently ...

  • Compiles ratings from 10 major wine periodicals
  • Features over 500 top-rated wines per issue
  • Fits into your pocket or purse for easy reference at the wine shop or the restaurant

PocketList will help you...

  • Select the best inexpensive and moderately-priced wines
  • Explore new wines virtually risk free
  • Always find a top-rated wine when shopping

The PocketList is published four times a year. Three issues focus on American wines, one on imported wines.

The PocketList online

From late 2002 the list was an online database for members. The About page of the 2003–2008 site opened like this:

Finally: A Proven Way to Reliably and Consistently Find and Drink Only the Best Wines

The Wine PocketList provides solid, believable wine ratings in a format you can use. We’ll help you find reasonably priced, highly-rated wines that you’ll have a chance of finding at a local store. We want you to explore new wines and varietals with confidence, without spending a fortune. Some great finds are even, dare we say, downright cheap.

How the grades were made is on the ratings system page, the member tools are under How it worked, the founder’s story is on John Vankat’s page, and what the press said is under Acclaim.