South Africa
A+ 3 · A 23 · A− 43 · B+ 58
South Africa’s 127 wines on the list came mostly from Stellenbosch, Western Cape, Paarl. 26 of them graded A or better.
Regions with their own page: Stellenbosch 60
Region
Grade
Price
Type
| Grade | Producer and wine | Vintage | Type | Region | Price | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| IE: individual evaluations: A plus | Groot Constantia | 2001 | Sauvignon Blanc | Constantia | $15 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A plus | WarwickThree Cape Ladies | 2000 | Cabernet Sauvignon / Merlot / Pinotage | Stellenbosch | $23 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A plus | MorgenhofReserve | 1998 | Cabernet Sauvignon | Stellenbosch | $30 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A | Goat-Roti | 2002 | Syrah | Western Cape | $18 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A | Neil EllisCabernet Sauvignon-Merlot | 1999 | Cabernet Sauvignon | Stellenbosch | $18 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A | SaxenburgPrivate Collection | 1998 | Pinotage | Stellenbosch | $18 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A, A minus | WarwickProfessor Black | 2003 | Sauvignon Blanc | Stellenbosch | $18 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A, A | Neil Ellis | 2000 | Chardonnay | Elgin | $19 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A | Mulderbosch | 2004 | Sauvignon Blanc | Western Cape | $20 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A, A, B plus | Mulderbosch | 1999 | Chardonnay | Stellenbosch | $22 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A | WarwickThree Cape Ladies | 2001 | Cabernet Sauvignon / Merlot / Pinotage | Stellenbosch | $22 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A | Groene Cloof | 1999 | Pinotage | Western Cape | $23 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A | BacksbergBabylon Toren | 2002 | Chardonnay | Paarl | $25 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A | De TraffordVin de Paille | 2000 | Chenin Blanc | Stellenbosch | $25 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A | Fairview | 2001 | Pinotage | Paarl | $25 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A | MorgenhofReserve | 1998 | Merlot | Stellenbosch | $25 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A | Kanonkop | 2001 | Pinotage | Stellenbosch | $28 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A | SlaleyShiraz, Hunting Family | 2000 | Syrah | Stellenbosch | $28 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A | WarwickEstate Reserve | 2000 | Cabernet Franc / Cabernet Sauvignon / Merlot | Stellenbosch | $29 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A | Culraithin | 2001 | Merlot | Paarl | $30 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A | De TorenFusion V | 2000 | Red | Coastal Region | $30 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A | GrangehurstCabernet Sauvignon-Merlot | 1998 | Cabernet Sauvignon | Stellenbosch | $30 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A | MorgenhofCabernet Sauvignon-Merlot, Centenaire Reserve | 1998 | Cabernet Sauvignon | Stellenbosch | $30 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A | Signal HillIce Wine, Vin de Glacière | 2000 | Sweet | Paarl | $30 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A | Thelema | 2000 | Cabernet Sauvignon | Stellenbosch | $30 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A | Thelema | 1999 | Cabernet Sauvignon | Stellenbosch | $30 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A minus | KWVFull Cream Sherry | NV | Sherry | Paarl | $8 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A minus, A minus | Brampton | 2001 | Sauvignon Blanc | Stellenbosch | $10 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A minus | KWV | 2000 | Cabernet Sauvignon | Western Cape | $10 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A minus | Cathedral | 2001 | Chardonnay | Western Cape | $12 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A minus | KWVRare Tawny Port, Vuurtoren | NV | Port | Robertson | $12 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A minus | Saxenburg | 1999 | Sauvignon Blanc | Stellenbosch | $12 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A minus | Villiera | 2003 | Sauvignon Blanc | Paarl | $12 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A minus | Jardin | 2000 | Sauvignon Blanc | Stellenbosch | $13 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A minus, B plus | KumkaniShiraz-Cabernet Sauvignon | 2000 | Syrah | Stellenbosch | $13 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A minus | Saxenburg | 1999 | Pinotage | Stellenbosch | $13 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A minus | Seidelberg | 2003 | Sauvignon Blanc | Paarl | $13 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A minus, A minus | Simonsig | 2000 | Pinotage | Stellenbosch | $13 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A minus, A minus | BoekenhoustskloofPorcupine Ridge | 2003 | Sauvignon Blanc | Western Cape | $14 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A minus | De WetshofBon Vallon | 2001 | Chardonnay | Robertson | $14 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A minus | Ken Forrester | 2003 | Sauvignon Blanc | Stellenbosch | $14 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A minus | Morgenhof | 1999 | Chardonnay | Stellenbosch | $14 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A minus | BacksbergJohn Martin | 2003 | Sauvignon Blanc | Paarl | $15 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A minus | Brampton | 2002 | Shiraz / Viognier | South Africa | $15 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A plus, B | Klein Constantia | 2001 | Sauvignon Blanc | Constantia | $15 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A minus, B plus | KumkaniShiraz | 2000 | Syrah | Stellenbosch | $15 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A, A, A minus, B plus, B | Neil Ellis | 2001 | Sauvignon Blanc | Western Cape | $15 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A minus | Signal HillVin de L'Empereur, Muscat d'Alexandrie | 2000 | Muscat | Paarl | $15 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A plus, B plus, B | Simonsig | 1998 | Cabernet Sauvignon | Stellenbosch | $15 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus, A | Thelema | 2002 | Sauvignon Blanc | Stellenbosch | $16 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A minus | DelheimShiraz | 1998 | Syrah | Stellenbosch | $17 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A minus | Pierre JourdanBrut | NV | Sparkling | Paarl | $17 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A, A minus, B plus | Thelema | 2001 | Sauvignon Blanc | Stellenbosch | $18 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A minus | Kaapzicht | 2001 | Syrah | South Africa | $19 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A minus | Neil Ellis | 2001 | Cabernet Sauvignon | Stellenbosch | $20 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A minus | Robertson WineryRetreat | 2003 | Sauvignon Blanc | Robertson | $20 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A, B plus | WarwickOld Bush Vines | 1999 | Pinotage | Stellenbosch | $20 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A minus, A minus | Hamilton Russell | 2001 | Chardonnay | Walker Bay | $22 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A minus | BellevueUmkhulu Titan | 2001 | Cabernet Franc / Cabernet Sauvignon / Malbec / Merlot | Stellenbosch | $23 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A minus | Mulderbosch | 2001 | Sauvignon Blanc | Western Cape | $24 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A, A minus | RustenbergJohn X Merriman | 1999 | Merlot | Stellenbosch | $25 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A minus | StellenzichtReserve | 2002 | Semillon | Stellenbosch | $25 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A, B plus | Kanonkop | 1999 | Pinotage | Stellenbosch | $27 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A minus | Thelema | 1999 | Merlot | Stellenbosch | $27 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A minus | Fairview | 2000 | Syrah | Paarl | $28 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A minus | FairviewThe Beacon | 2002 | Syrah | South Africa | $28 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A minus | Kanonkop | 2000 | Pinotage | Stellenbosch | $28 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A minus | WarwickEstate Reserve | 2001 | Cabernet Franc / Cabernet Sauvignon / Merlot | Stellenbosch | $29 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A minus | Culraithin | 2002 | Syrah | Paarl | $30 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | Two Oceans | 2001 | Syrah | Western Cape | $7 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | Du Preez | 2001 | Sauvignon Blanc | Goudini Valley | $9 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | Guardian Peak | 2001 | Syrah | Western Cape | $9 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus, B | Malan | 1999 | Pinotage | Stellenbosch | $9 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | Baobab | 2001 | Pinotage | Western Cape | $10 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | Brampton | 2001 | Chardonnay | Stellenbosch | $10 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | Brampton | 2002 | Sauvignon Blanc | Coastal Region | $10 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | Fairview | 2003 | Sauvignon Blanc | Paarl | $10 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | Goats do RoamRosé | 2000 | Rosé | South Africa | $10 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | Guardian Peak | 2001 | Cabernet Sauvignon | Stellenbosch | $10 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | KWV | 2001 | Merlot | Western Cape | $10 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | Robertson Winery | 2003 | Sauvignon Blanc | Robertson | $10 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | Robertson Winery | 2004 | Cabernet Sauvignon | Robertson | $10 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus, B, B, B plus | Simonsig | 2000 | Chardonnay | Stellenbosch | $10 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | Du PreezPolla's Red | 2000 | Red | South Africa | $11 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | Du Preez | 2000 | Merlot | Goudini Valley | $11 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | FairviewShiraz | 2000 | Syrah | South Africa | $11 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | FairviewShiraz | 2000 | Syrah | Coastal Region | $11 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | Nederburg | 2003 | Pinotage | Western Cape | $11 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | Rietvallei Estate WineMuscadel | 2002 | Muscat | Robertson | $11 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | Roodeberg | 1998 | Red | Western Cape | $11 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | Boschendal | 2002 | Sauvignon Blanc | Coastal Region | $12 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | KanonkopKadette | 2001 | Red | Stellenbosch | $12 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | Laborie | 2001 | Cabernet Sauvignon | Paarl | $12 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | Morgenhof Estate | 2002 | Sauvignon Blanc | Stellenbosch | $12 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | Seidelberg | 2004 | Sauvignon Blanc | Paarl | $12 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A minus, B | Amani | 2001 | Sauvignon Blanc | Stellenbosch | $13 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | DakensigCoastal | 2001 | Cabernet Sauvignon | Coastal Region | $13 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus, B | Fairview | 2000 | Pinotage | Coastal Region | $13 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | JardinFumé Blanc | 1999 | Sauvignon Blanc | Stellenbosch | $13 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | KanuLimited Release | 2002 | Sauvignon Blanc | Stellenbosch | $13 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | Kanu | 2004 | Sauvignon Blanc | Stellenbosch | $13 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | KWVRoodeberg | 2001 | Red | Western Cape | $13 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | Pine Crest | 2000 | Chardonnay | Franschhoek | $13 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | Porcupine Ridge | 2001 | Merlot | Coastal Region | $13 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A minus, B | Waterford | 2000 | Sauvignon Blanc | Stellenbosch | $13 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | BoschendalGrande Cuvée | 2002 | Sauvignon Blanc | Coastal Region | $14 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus, B | Kanu | 2001 | Sauvignon Blanc | Stellenbosch | $14 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | Mulderbosch | 2002 | Chenin Blanc | Stellenbosch | $14 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | Mulderbosch | 2003 | Sauvignon Blanc | Western Cape | $14 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | Neil Ellis | 2003 | Sauvignon Blanc | Western Cape | $14 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | SimonsigShiraz | 1999 | Syrah | Stellenbosch | $14 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | BellevueAtticus | 2001 | Cabernet Sauvignon / Pinotage | Stellenbosch | $15 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A minus, B | Buitenverwachting | 2001 | Sauvignon Blanc | Constantia | $15 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | Buitenverwachting | 2001 | Chardonnay | Constantia | $15 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | Cathedral | 1999 | Cabernet Sauvignon | Coastal Region | $15 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A, B, B plus | Clos Malverne | 2001 | Sauvignon Blanc | Stellenbosch | $15 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | Clos Malverne | 2003 | Sauvignon Blanc | Stellenbosch | $15 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus, B | Moreson | 2001 | Sauvignon Blanc | Paarl | $15 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | Neil Ellis | 2004 | Sauvignon Blanc | Western Cape | $15 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | Nitida | 2003 | Sauvignon Blanc | Durbanville | $15 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: A minus, B | Saxenburg | 1998 | Cabernet Sauvignon | Stellenbosch | $15 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | Clos Malverne | 2000 | Cabernet Sauvignon / Shiraz | Stellenbosch | $16 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | Neil Ellis | 2003 | Chardonnay | Stellenbosch | $17 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | Lanzerac | 2003 | Chardonnay | Stellenbosch | $20 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | Rust en Vrede | 1999 | Cabernet Sauvignon | Stellenbosch | $20 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | FairviewPegleg | 2001 | Carignane | Paarl | $25 | |
| IE: individual evaluations: B plus | FairviewOom Pagel | 2001 | Sémillon | Paarl | $25 | |
Grades are composites of the critics’ reviews the PocketList found, Nov 1999 to Mar 2006. How the grades worked then. Prices are what each wine cost when it was reviewed.