Straight Talk about Wine
Bottle Problems
The other day, someone told my wife that he had tried my Wine of the Week recommendation from The Cincinnati Enquirer. He paused for dramatic effect and stated “it was the worst bottle of wine I’d had in a long time.”
Ouch.
Are our tastes that different?
Maybe.
Was there something wrong with his bottle?
Possibly.
Am I incapable of recommending good wines?
Nah!
My best guess is that our tastes are not that different. Rather, something was wrong with the bottle. (Notice how I disregarded the third possibility.)
So what can ruin a bottle? Well, the beauty of wine is that it is dynamic. While this usually works to our advantage, sometimes it doesn’t.
The most common problem is “corky” or “corked” wine, where the wine smells like wet moldy newspaper. If you’re uncertain about this odor, send $3 to The Wine Trader, Attention “Corky”, P.O. Box 1598, Carson City, NV 89702.
In return, you’ll receive a small sample of the chemical believed responsible for corked wines, along with directions on how to use it to identify corked wines. It’s worth three bucks, but you won’t want to keep it around the house!
A better known but less common problem is wine that has turned to vinegar. As the authors of Wine for Dummies write, “Wine is just a pit stop between grape juice and vinegar”.
But fortunately wine is much longer than an Indy 500 pit stop and only occasionally do you find a wine that has moved back onto the racetrack to vinegar.
Yet another problem is wine that smells and tastes flat or weak, or perhaps cooked or baked. These odors come from wines that have been oxidized from air having gotten into the bottle or from exposure to high heat somewhere between the winery and your table. Beware of a loose cork that has raised slightly in the neck of the bottle, or signs of leakage around a cork.
Should you have a bad bottle, don’t wait for someone from the winery to speed to your home with a replacement, as in the old television advertisements about “skunky” beer.
Just return the almost full bottle to the store – unless of course the problem originated in your home, such as if you stored wine in a hot kitchen. The store manager should offer to replace it with another bottle of the same wine.
While bad bottles are obvious, it is more difficult to identify a wine that has been only slightly affected. It may taste no worse than a lower quality wine.
Variation in wine can be a problem for anyone. Occasionally after publishing a Wine of the Week, I’ve tasted a second bottle and found it lower in quality. That can be embarrassing, but now you know some reasons for it.
– John Vankat
– John Vankat