From the Wine PocketList archives, 1994–2007Written for Coastal Living (manuscript dated June 17, 2004)

From the PocketList, in print

The Case for Wine

Wine columnist and author Michael Hinshaw is also publisher of the online Wine PocketList [winepocketlist.com]. His free monthly newsletter, VinConnections, reaches over 80,000 wine lovers a month. Here, he’s selected wines that pair up with our (crusted fish) dishes.

“When choosing wines to pair with seafood dishes like these, the choices are as myriad as the intensely personal ways we enjoy both food and wine. In fact, choosing great wine for fish is no different than choosing wine for any food, cooking style or occasion. Because when it comes to wine, there’s no hard and fast “rule” for pairing it with food—it’s all about what tastes good to you.

With this in mind, I’ve picked several highly-rated wines under $30 that I think you’ll savor as you enjoy these crispy and flavorful fish recipes.”

Bacon and Parmesan Crusted Tilapia

Chateau Souverain

2002 Chardonnay, “Sonoma County”

Sonoma County, California

(about $14, and rated an A−)

The fruit in this full-flavored, buttery Chardonnay from the warmer climate of Sonoma County’s Alexander Valley complements the smoke of the bacon, and the brings out the nuttiness of the baked parmesan.

Other great Chardonnays to try include the “A+” rated 2002 Keller “La Cruz Vineyard,” also from the Sonoma Coast area, ($28), or some of the many “A” rated Chardonnays under $20, including the 2002 Rosemount “Hill of Gold, Mudgee” from Australia ($13). And a bargain at under $10, enjoy Esser Cellars 2001 “California” ($9), rated “A−”.

Cornmeal and Cumin Crusted Shrimp

Ponzi

2002 Pinot Gris, “Willamette Valley”

Willamette Valley, Oregon

(A “Buy-by-the-Case” wine; about $13, and rated an A−)

The cumin and shrimp combination beg for a crisp, lively wine with a mild nose. Less acidic than Riesling and livelier than Chardonnay, Ponzi’s Pinot Gris adds a flavorful, spicy nuance to the dish and is a great example of the many excellent Pinot Gris wines hailing from the vineyards of Oregon’s Willamette Valley.

If you’re interested in trying other wines of this type, you may also enjoy 2002 from Elk Cove ($15, “A”). From California, the “A+” rated 2002 MacMurray Ranch from Sonoma County’s Russian River Valley ($23), or the Lorca 2001 Pinot Gris from Monterey County ($15, “A−”) won’t disappoint.

Macadamia Crusted Striped Bass with Mango-Lime Salsa

Groth

2002 Sauvignon Blanc, “Napa Valley”

Napa Valley, California

(This “Buy-by-the-Case” wine is about $15, and rated an A)

The lush, citrus character of Groth’s 2002 Sauvignon Blanc, balances with a clean, crisp finish that would be an especially good complement to the mango-lime salsa. Though nearly colorless in the glass, this wine demands attention as soon as you bring it to your nose. At $15, you may want to have a few extra bottles handy.

Other Sauvignon Blancs worth the taste include two South African notables: the 2003 Seidelberg ($13, A−), and the 2003 Warwick “Professor Black, Simonsberg” ($16, A). Also on the international front, enjoy the 2003 Groom “Adelaide Hills” ($16, A−) as well as the stunningly good 2003 Logan “Orange” ($15, A+), both from Australia.

Potato-Chive Crusted Halibut

Acacia

2002 Pinot Noir “Carneros”

Napa Valley, California

(This “Widely Available” wine is about $20, and is rated an A−)

The suppleness of Pinot Noir in general – and this wine in particular – allows it to pair effortlessly with a wide variety of foods. Its gentle fruit flavors complement a simple dish like this. And with a production run of over 20,000 cases, it should be relatively easy to find at your local bottle shop. Though the 2000 and 2001 vintages are not as highly rated as the 2002, (B+) they’re still worth trying.

For a true bargain, the 2001 Pinot Noir from Gallo of Sonoma “Reserve, Sonoma Coast” ($8; A−) will prove that price and quality don’t always go hand-in-hand when it comes to great wine. And though not as well priced, the quality of the 2001 Sebastiani “Sonoma Coast, Sonoma County” ($15, A) handily beats dozens of other Pinot Noirs more than twice the price.

Salt Crusted Sea Bass with Rosemary and Lemon

Grosset

2003 Riesling, “Polish Hill”

Clare Valley, South Australia

(Both a “Splurge” and “Buy-by-the-Case” wine; about $29 and rated an A+)

Though a light Italian red would also complement the rosemary and lemon in this dish, I’ve chosen the bone-dry style of this Australian Riesling that not only boasts the “food appeal” of the Alsace (French) style Rieslings, but sports a bit more of the fruit and floral fragrance of the traditional German style.

Other dry Rieslings from Australia’s Clare Valley include the 2003 Jim Barry “The Lodge Hill Riesling” (Buy-by-the Case; A−) and the 2003 Petaluma “Hamlin Hill Vineyard” ($16, A−). Another is the 2003 Pewsey Vale “Eden Valley” ($15, A−) that underscores the stunning price/quality mix you’ll find in Australian Rieslings.

Sesame Crusted Scallop and Spinach Salad and Asian Vinaigrette

Pierre Sparr, 2001 Gewürztraminer, “Réserve”

Alsace, France

(This “Buy-by-the-Case” wine is about $15, and is rated A)

Echoing a grand tradition (a James Beard dinner in New York paired a ’98 with a salad of sweetbreads, lobster, blood orange and asparagus with vinaigrette) the ’01 Pierre Spar is a smooth yet aromatically fruity wine with a big, velvety palate. It will enhance the scallops and vinaigrette, without overpowering you with sweet fruit flavors.

Other Gewürztraminers in the dry, Alsatian tradition include the bargain priced ($7, B+) 2002 Covey Run from Washington state, as well as the 2002 vintages from Canoe Ridge (“Oak Ridge Vineyard”; $13, A−) and Woodward Canyon (“Dry White, Columbia Valley”; $13, A−).